DIP66

Title:	(Multiple) alias this
DIP:	66
Version:	1
Status:	Draft
Created:	2014-10-09
Last Modified:	2014-10-19
Author:	Igor Stepanov
Links:

Abstract

An AliasThis declaration names a member to subtype. Multiple AliasThis declarations are allowed. Order of AliasThis declarations does not matter.

Description

In the code below...

    struct Foo
    {
        //...
        alias symbol this;
    }

... the construction alias symbol this; means that wherever typeof(Foo.symbol) is needed, obj (object of type Foo) can be substituted with obj.symbol. This rule applies to implicit and explicit conversion, .member access expression, operator overloading, foreach expression (foreach(args; obj)) etc. symbol can be a field or a get-property (method annotated with @property and taking zero parameters). If more than one alias this can be used to solve the same lookup, the compiler should raise an error.

    struct A
    {
        int i;
        alias i this;
    }

    struct B
    {
        int i;
        alias i this;
    }

    struct C
    {
        A a;
        B b;

        alias a this;
        alias b this;
    }
    
    void test()
    {
        C c;
        int i = c; //Error: c.a.i vs c.b.i
    }
    
    static assert(is(C : int)); //Ok, because C is subtype of int anyway.

Semantics

Multiple alias this can cause conflicts. This section explains how the compiler should resolve them. At the AliasThis declaration semantic stage, compiler can perform the initial checks and reject the obviously incorrect AliasThis declarations.

    struct Test1
    {
        int a;
        int b;
        alias a this;
        alias b this; // Error: alias b this conflicts with alias a this;
    }

    class Test2a
    {
    }

    class Test2b : Test2a
    {
    }

    class Test2 : Test2b
    {
        Test2a a;
        alias a this; //Error: alias a this tries to hide inherited type Test2a; 
    }

The other checks will be done when alias this is needed for typing expressions. When the compiler types an expression such as fun(a), it can resolve it as fun(a.aliasThisSymbol). (Hereinafter fun(a) means any case when alias this can be used: type conversion, .member expression, operator expression etc.) However compiler will try fun(a.aliasThisSymbol) only if the expression cannot be typed otherwise. E.g. while running semantic obj.member, the compiler will search for .member among obj's members, base class members, will try to use opDispatch and if all that fails, the compiler will try alias this. However alias this will be tried before UFCS resolving.

When the compiler is trying to resolve alias this it iterates all alias this declarations and tries to apply each. For each successful application, the compiler adds the result expression into a result set. If application fails, the compiler tries to recursively resolve the alias this expression. The following pseudo-code illustrates this:

   resolveAliasThis(obj, ex):
       Set resultSet;
       foreach currentAliasThis in obj.aliasThisSymbols do
           if try(`ex(obj.currentAliasThis))` == Success then
               resultSet.add(`ex(obj.currentAliasThis)`)
           else
               resultSet.add(resolveAliasThis(`obj.currentAliasThis`, ex))
       if obj is class then
           foreach currentBaseClass in obj.baseClasses do
               resultSet.add(resolveAliasThis(`cast(currentBaseClass)obj`, ex))
       return resultSet

Finally, if resultSet contains only one candidate, the compiler will accept it. If resultSet is empty, compiler tries another ways to resolve ex(obj): UFCS et c. If resultSet contains more then one candidates, the compiler raises an error.

Recursive alias this may occur:

    class A
    {
        C c;
        alias c this;
    }

    class B
    {
        A a;
        alias a this;
    }

    class C
    {
        B b;
        alias b this;
    }

For resolving this situation, the resolveAliasThis function stores a set of types (visitedTypes), which can be visited higher in the call stack. If visitedTypes contains typeof(obj), compiler will not check obj's subtypes.

When compiler resolves binary expressions, where both arguments have a alias this declarations, compiler proceeds as follows: At the first stage compiler tries to resolve alias this only for one term: binex(a, b) -> binex(a.aliasthis, b) binex(a, b) -> binex(a, b.aliasthis)

If there is only one candidate, compiler chooses it, if there are many candidates, compiler raises an error. If there isn't candidates, compiler tries to resolve both terms: binex(a, b) -> binex(a.aliasthis, b.aliasthis) If there is only one candidate, compiler chooses it. If there are several candidates, compiler raises an error.