DIP25

DIP25: Sealed references

Title:	Sealed references
DIP:	25
Version:	1
Status:	Draft
Created:	2013-02-05
Last Modified:	2013-02-05
Author:	Andrei Alexandrescu and Walter Bright
Links:

Abstract

D offers a number of features aimed at systems-level coding, such as unrestricted pointers, casting between integers and pointers, and the @system attribute. These means, combined with the other features of D, make it a complete and expressive language for systems-level tasks. On the other hand, economy of means should be exercised in defining such powerful but dangerous features. Most other features should offer good safety guarantees with little or no loss in efficiency or expressiveness. This proposal makes ref provide such a guarantee: with the proposed rules, it is impossible in safe code to have ref refer to a destroyed object. The restrictions introduced are not backward compatible, but disallow code that is stylistically questionable and that can be easily replaced either with equivalent and clearer code.

Description

Currently, D has some provisions for avoiding dangling references:

ref int fun(int x) {
  return x; // Error: escaping reference to local variable x 
}

ref int gun() {
  int x;
  return x; // Error: escaping reference to local variable x 
}

However, this enforcement is shallow. The following code compiles and allows reads and writes through defunct stack locations, bypassing scoping and lifetime rules:

ref int id(ref int x) {
  return x; 
}

ref int fun(int x) {
  return id(x); 
}

ref int gun() {
  int x;
  return id(x); 
}

The escape pattern is obvious in this simple example with all code in sight, and may be found automatically. The problem is that generally the compiler cannot see the body of id. We need to devise a method for compiling such functions separately.

We want to devise rules that allow us to pass objects by reference down into functions, and return references up from functions, while disallowing cases such as the above when a reference passed up ends up referring to a deallocated temporary.

Typechecking rules

The rules below discuss under what circumstances functions receiving and/or returning ref T may be called, where T is some arbitrary type. Let us also denote with ST any struct that has a non-static member variable of type T.

1. An invocation of a function that takes a parameter of type ref T may pass one of the following:
   1. An lvalue of type T, including function arguments, array and struct members;
   2. An incoming ref T parameter or a member of type T of ST received as ref ST
   3. The result of a function returning ref T, or a member of ST returned as ref ST.
2. A function that returns a ref T may return one of the following:
   1. A static lvalue of type T, including members of static struct values;
   2. A member variable of type T belonging to a class object;
   3. A ref T parameter;
   4. A member of type T of ST that has been passed as ref ST into the function;
   5. The invocation of a function fun returning ref T IF fun does NOT take any parameters of type T or ST.
   6. The invocation of a function fun returning ref T IF none of fun's parameters of type ref T and ref S are bound to local variables.

Discussion and Examples

The rules allow unrestricted pass-down and conservatively restrict pass-up to avoid escaping values. Itemized discussion follows.

1.1 Regular lvalues can be passed down:

void fun(ref T);

struct S { int a; T b; }

void caller(T v1, S v2) {
    static T v3;
    T v4;
    static S v5;
    S v6;

    // Fine: pass argument
    fun(v1);
    // Fine: pass member of argument
    fun(v2.b);
    // Fine: pass static lvalue
    fun(v3);
    // Fine: pass of stack variable
    fun(v4);
    // Fine: pass member of static struct
    fun(v5.b);
    // Fine: pass member of local struct
    fun(v6.b);
}

1.2. This rule allows forwarding references transitively.

void fun(ref T);

struct S { int a; T b; }

void caller(ref T v1, ref S v2) {
    // Fine: pass ref argument
    fun(v1);
    // Fine: pass member of ref argument
    fun(v2.b);
}

1.3. This rule enables passing down references obtained from other function calls.

void fun(ref T);
ref T gun();
struct S { int a; T b; }
ref S hun();

void caller() {
    // Fine: pass ref result
    fun(gun());
    // Fine: pass member of ref result
    fun(hun().b);
}

2.1. Static lvalues can be returned:

struct S { int a; T b; }
static T v1;
static S v2;

ref T caller(bool condition) {
    static T v3;
    static S v4;
    // Fine
    if (condition) return fun(v1);
    if (condition) return fun(v2);
    if (condition) return fun(v3);
    if (condition) return fun(v4);
}

2.2.Member variables of classes can be returned because they live on the garbage-collected heap:

class C { int a; T b; }

ref T caller() {
    auto c = new C;
    return c.b;
}

2.3. This rule allows returning back an incoming parameter, which in turn allows implementing the identity function and idioms derived from it.

ref T fun(ref T v1) {
    return v1;
}

2.4. As above, but for members of structs.

struct S { int a; T b; }
ref T fun(ref S v1) {
    return v1.b;
}

2.5. This allows to pass up the result of a function that has no chance at all to return a reference to a local.

// Assume T is not double or string
ref T fun(double, ref string);
struct S { int a; T b; }
ref S gun(double, ref string);

ref T caller(bool condition, ref T v1) {
    string s = "asd";
    if (condition) return fun(1, s);
    return gun(1, s).b;
}

2.6. This is the most sophisticated rule. It allows passing up the result of a function while disallowing those cases in which the function may actually return a reference to a local.

ref T fun(T);
ref T gun(ref T);
struct S { int a; T b; }
ref S hun(S);
ref S iun(ref S);

ref T caller(bool condition, ref T v1, ref S v2, T v3, S v4) {
    T v5;
    S v6;

    // Fine, no ref parameters
    if (condition) return fun(v1);
    if (condition) return fun(v2.b);
    if (condition) return fun(v3);
    if (condition) return fun(v4.b);
    if (condition) return fun(v5);
    if (condition) return fun(v6.b);

    // Fine, bound to ref parameters
    if (condition) return gun(v1);
    if (condition) return gun(v2.b);

    // Not fine, bound to locals
    // if (condition) return gun(v3);
    // if (condition) return gun(v4.b);
    // if (condition) return gun(v5);
    // if (condition) return gun(v6.b);

    // Fine, no ref at all
    if (condition) return hun(v2).b;
    if (condition) return hun(v4).b;
    if (condition) return hun(v6).b;

    // Fine, ref bound to ref argument
    if (condition) return iun(v2).b;

    // Not fine, bound to locals
    // if (condition) return iun(v4);
    // if (condition) return iun(v6);
}

Member functions

The rules above apply to member functions as well, considering that the this special parameter in a method belonging to type A is passed as a ref A parameter. This may cause problems with rvalue structs. (Currently, D allows calling a method against a struct rvalue.) Special rules concerning struct rvalues may be necessary.

Taking address

This proposal introduces a related restriction: taking the address of the following entities shall be disallowed, even in @system.

• Parameters (either value or ref)
• Stack-allocated locals.
• Member variables of a struct if the struct is a parameter (either value or ref) or stack-allocated.
  • Note that using a pointer to a struct does allow taking the address of a member.
  • Also note that a struct that is part of a class object also allows address taking.
• The result of functions that return ref.

This is because escaping pointers away from expressions is too dangerous and should be more explicit. The capability must still be present, otherwise very simple uses are not possible anymore. Consider:

bool parse1(ref double v) {
    // Use C's scanf
    return scanf("%f", &v) == 1; // Error: cannot take the address of v
}

double parse2() {
    // Use C's scanf, 2nd try
    double v;
    enforce(scanf("%f", &v) == 1); // Error: cannot take the address of v
    return v;
}

double parse3() {
    // Use C's scanf, 2nd try
    auto pv = new double;
    enforce(scanf("%f", pv) == 1); // Fine
    return *pv;
}

That would force many variables to exist on the heap even though it's easy to figure that the code is safe since the semantics of scanf is understood by the programmer. To address this issue, this proposal fosters introducing a standard function with the signature:

@system T* addressOf(ref T value);

The function returns the address of value and can only be used in @system or @trusted code. addressOf itself cannot use the & address-of operator because it's forbidden even in @system code. But there are many possible implementations, including escaping into C or assembler. One possible portable implementation is:

@system T* addressOf(ref T value) {
    static T* id(T* p) { return p; }
    auto pfun = cast(T* function(ref T)) id;
    return *pfun(value);
}

This relies on the fact that at binary level a ref parameter is passed as a pointer.

With this function available as part of the standard library, efficient code can be written that forwards to scanf without the compiler knowing its semantics:

bool parse1(ref double v) {
    // Use C's scanf
    return scanf("%f", addressOf(v)) == 1; // Fine
}

double parse2() {
    // Use C's scanf, 2nd try
    double v;
    enforce(scanf("%f", addressOf(v)) == 1); // Fine
    return v;
}

Copyright

This document has been placed in the Public Domain.